Best Antidepressant: Information to discuss with your doctor

Best Antidepressant: Information to discuss with your doctor

Which is the best antidepressant?

There are 3 important facts to remember about our current state of knowledge:-

  • We do not know what is wrong in depression.
  • We do not know how antidepressants fix depression
  • Therefore, there is no way of predicting which antidepressant will be “the best”.

Any antidepressant has the same unpredictable chance of producing the following results:

  1. Long term very good effect called remission – 40%
  2. Short term very good effect – 15%
  3. Partial benefit only – 15%
  4. No benefit – 30%

So, in the inevitable sequence of trial and error, please remember a few points

  • This site guides you to the antidepressants with the fewest side-effects in the clinical opinion of the author
  • The antidepressant with fundamentally no side-effects (Valdoxan, the one I would try first if I had depression..David Horgan) has been shown in a recent Cochrane review (the most prestigious reference source in Medicine in general) to be as effective as any other antidepressant.
  • Start with a low dose of any antidepressant for the first 2-4 days, especially in those under 25
  • If no brief periods of improvement occur in the first 3 weeks, it is 90% certain that antidepressant is never going to work in that patient, and a trial of another antidepressant is indicated.
  • Depression is like mental cancer, and needs prolonged “chemotherapy” to prevent it recurring (which will happen in 50% of cases), so antidepressants should be taken for 12 months initially according to research!
  • Keep long-term side-effects in mind, not reported in initial drug trials. 30-40% of patients on SSRIs or SNRIs will gain weight (mainly due to metabolic changes), 30-40% will develop sexual side-effects, and about 30% will develop withdrawal symptoms as if they were addicted.

Disclosure: I have received lecturing fees, consultancy fees and travel grants from multiple different pharmaceutical companies…David Horgan